Skip to content
Demo build

sample content Nothing here is a real recommendation yet. How we’ll choose

The other half of the job

Stuff you don’t need

A buying publication that only ever says buy this is an advertisement with a serif font. These pieces cost us money, which is precisely why they get a page of their own rather than a footnote.

2 entries

Stuff You Don't Need

Extended warranties on televisions

Skip

The extended warranty is a product sold to the anxious

Panel failures in modern televisions cluster in the first ninety days, which the manufacturer already covers, or after year seven, which the extended plan does not. The middle years — the ones you are being sold insurance for — are the years almost nothing happens. The margin on these plans is the reason the salesperson's demeanour changes when you decline.

Smart fridges

Skip

A fifteen-year appliance with a four-year computer glued to it

The screen will keep working long after the software behind it stops. You will own a dark rectangle in your kitchen that cannot be uninstalled. Buy the dumb version of the same fridge, which is usually mechanically identical and several hundred dollars cheaper, and put a tablet on a magnet if you want a calendar.

1 entry

Don't Buy This Yet

8K televisions

Not yet

There is nothing to watch, and there won't be for a while

There is effectively no 8K content available to a normal household, upscaling from 4K produces a difference you cannot see at domestic viewing distances, and the panels cost multiples of a very good 4K set. This will change. It has not changed yet, and buying early does not reserve you a place in the queue.

1 entry

Wait for the New Model

Mid-range robot vacuums

Wait

If you can hold out until November, hold out

The refresh cycle in this category is unusually predictable and unusually consequential: docks get better, navigation gets better, and last year's model drops by a third within a fortnight of the announcement. Our current pick is still the right buy today. It will be a $150 better buy in three months, and it is not an urgent purchase.

1 entry

Good Product, Stupid Price

$299 electric toothbrushes

$$$

A good toothbrush attached to a screen that tells you where your teeth are

The motor at the top of the range is the same motor that appears three rungs down. What the extra $220 buys is a travel case, a display, and an app that awards you points for an activity you were going to perform anyway. It is a genuinely good toothbrush. It is a stupid price.

1 entry

Everyone Recommends This. We Don't.

1 entry

Tucker Wouldn't Buy It

Robot vacuums between $700 and $1,100

No

The dead zone

Too expensive to be a simple vacuum, too cheap to mop in a way that would survive inspection. This band exists because it is where the marketing department found the most people, not because it is where the good machines are. Buy below it or above it.

1 entry

We Changed Our Mind

Bose QuietComfort Ultra

We optimised for a measurement instead of for wearing them

We recommended the Bose outright on the strength of its cancellation figures. Two weeks of side-by-side listening changed our view: the Sony is more pleasant for the four-hour stretches that are the actual use case, and cancellation depth past a certain point stops being the thing you notice. The Bose remains the pick if silence is the only goal. We should have said that the first time.

Full-length

Guides with no winner

Sometimes the whole category fails, and that deserves an article rather than a paragraph.

Home

Nobody Should Buy a Smart Fridge

No winner — on purpose

There is no correct smart fridge. Buy the dumb version of the same fridge and put a $12 whiteboard on it.

Verdict standsUPD Aug 14, 2026